I am not on the pill, but I am on the depo-provera shot and I have no problems with it interacting with my PTU or anything. It seems to work just great. Not being on any birth control can be a problem. The reason he may not let you on the pill is because it peaks once a month and people with Graves hyper-ovulate so it isn’t that effective. Rather than needing a peak once a month you may need a peak of 2 or 3 times a month.