Forum Replies Created
-
AuthorPosts
-
in reply to: TT and eye disease symptoms #1184584
@Shirley – The most well-known studies (Bartalena 1998 and Traisk 2009) left out thyroidectomy. However, the link that I included a few posts above is from UM Kellogg and found a reduced risk of TED for patients undergoing surgery.
This is also an interesting read from last year from Dr. Bartalena:
(Note on links: if you click directly on the following link, you will need to use your browser’s “back” button to return to the boards after viewing, or you will have to log back in to the forum. As an alternative, you can right-click the link and open it in a new tab or new window).
in reply to: I hate Graves Disease #1184575@Sandy40 – Links here can only be posted from specific sources; below is an excerpt from our forum guidelines that addresses links:
Posting of Links. Posted links must either come from (a) a well-established, peer-reviewed medical journal (ex: New England Journal of Medicine, The Journal of Clinical Endocrinology and Metabolism, Thyroid, etc.) or (b) an established medical association or governmental entity (American Association of Clinical Endocrinologists, American Thyroid Association, National Institutes of Health, etc.) that provides information guided by “evidence-based medicine”.
You can read more about our guidelines and the rationale behind them here:
in reply to: TT and eye disease symptoms #1184577Hello – I’m aware of one study out of University of Michigan Kellogg Eye Center that indicated that thyroidectomy could potentially reduce the risk of thyroid eye disease:
(Note on links: if you click directly on the following link, you will need to use your browser’s “back” button to return to the boards after viewing, or you will have to log back in to the forum. As an alternative, you can right-click the link and open it in a new tab or new window).
http://kellogg.umich.edu/news/14/thyroid-eye-disease.html
I’ve also heard a couple of anecdotal stories from patients who saw an improvement in thyroid eye disease symptoms after surgery.
I’ve not seen *any* research that indicates thyroid eye disease gets worse after thyroidectomy.
Of course, as Dr. David Granet from UC Shiley Eye Institute noted at a seminar earlier this year, “when you’ve seen one case of Graves’ disease, you’ve seen one case of Graves’ disease. In other words, your mileage may vary!
in reply to: I hate Graves Disease #1184572Sandy40 wrote:Thank you for your advise, I have asked multiple times, gone to several doctors and due to my age 40 they don’t want to investigate my slurring and stuttering, I am often told it is the weakness from the facial muscles as a result of leakage of minerals from my muscles into my blood stream.Obviously, I’m a fellow patient, not a doctor, but if it was me, I’d seek a third, fourth, or fifth opinion. There are many different medical conditions (not to mention medication interactions) that can cause slurring, and all of them should be ruled out.
The vast majority of our members here have been very happy with surgery as a treatment option – but you don’t want to assume that surgery will give you relief from an issue that could be coming from other causes!
in reply to: I hate Graves Disease #1184570Sandy40 wrote:I am now considering extreme radical measures to deal with these hormones but I will give conventional medicine a chance to make me better first.Liz1967 is correct that this is *not* an issue that can be fixed by diet or supplements (or any other so-called “alternative” therapy). Some assume that alternative cures are risk-free, but this is not the case. The biggest issue with these alternative approaches is that they probably won’t control your levels. And if you go extremely hyper or hypo because your treatment isn’t working, both come with significant risks.
Again, I would encourage you to find a doctor to help you get to the bottom of the slurred speech – to determine whether that is due to out of balance thyroid levels or some other underlying cause.
in reply to: I hate Graves Disease #1184563Hello and welcome – we have a number of regular posters here who have chosen surgery as their treatment option. Hopefully, they will chime in, but you can also use the “search posts” feature when you are logged in to search for keywords such as thyroidectomy, “thyroid surgery”, etc..
You noted that you are not responding to medication, but hopefully, your endocrinologist is looking at Free T4 and T3 as well as TSH in making this determination. TSH can remain suppressed in Graves’ patients and is not a good benchmark to be used alone in monitoring the course of the disease.
Also, your primary care doc should be looking into other potential causes for the slurred speech. I’ve heard of this more commonly with hypo than hyper – but there are many other causes as well, all of which should be checked out.
Here are a few resources that will hopefully be of interest as you make your decision:
(Note on links: if you click directly on the following link, you will need to use your browser’s “back” button to return to the boards after viewing, or you will have to log back in to the forum. As an alternative, you can right-click the link and open it in a new tab or new window).
American Association of Endocrine Surgeons:
http://endocrinediseases.org/thyroid/surgery.shtmlGDATF Bulletin:
http://gdatf.org/about/about-graves-disease/patient-education/thyroidectomy-for-graves-surgical-option/GDATF Conference video:
in reply to: On Week 12 and very discouraged #1184496Hopefully, your doctor is looking at Free T4 and T3 in making dosing decisions. TSH can remain suppressed for a while with Graves’ patients, so if that is the only test done, it’s fairly common for patients to eventually go extremely hypo. If your doc isn’t looking at T3/T4, definitely ask for these tests to be run.
Hopefully, you will start feeling better soon.
in reply to: 3 year old with graves #1177617Liz1967 wrote:Just one study. Methimazole is not a totally innocuous drug. Agranulocytosis is a bone marrow problem that is a known side effect of antithyroid drugs.It’s important to note that this was not a study – it was a case report of a single individual and a review of existing literature. Wendyh’s doctor referred to “problems with bone marrow which is non curative”. In the case reported in this article, the individual recovered after discontinuing the meds.
I agree 100% that methimazole is not a “totally innocuous drug” – every single patient that takes this med should be aware of the risk of agranulocytosis and liver issues, as well as less serious side effects. However, patients should also be made aware that these issues occur more frequently early in treatment and also generally at higher doses.
ALL three treatment options have risks. As patients (or parents of a small child), the best that we can do is fully understand all of the risks, to make sure that our questions have been fully answered by our medical provider, seek a second (or third or fourth) opinion if necessary, and then to make the best decision that we can.
in reply to: 3 year old with graves #1177613Hello – I have never heard of a bone marrow issue with anti-thyroid meds. You might ask to see if there is a specific study that the doctor has seen that I have not. Certainly, though, it’s worth meeting the additional specialists to learn about the pros and cons of RAI and surgery vs. continuing to stay on the medication.
I would NOT try any sort of herbal therapy without letting your daughter’s doctor know exactly which supplements she is taking, as there are some that can actually make hyperthyroidism worse. And I would *definitely* not recommend discontinuing the meds and pursing any sort of alternative type of therapy.
Wishing you and your family all the best!
in reply to: 3 year old with graves #1177612Hello – I have never heard of a bone marrow issue with anti-thyroid meds. You might ask to see if there is a specific study that the doctor has seen that I have not. Certainly, though, it’s worth meeting the additional specialists to learn about the pros and cons of RAI and surgery vs. continuing to stay on the medication.
I would NOT try any sort of herbal therapy without letting your daughter’s doctor know exactly which supplements she is taking, as there are some that can actually make hyperthyroidism worse. And I would *definitely* not recommend discontinuing the meds and pursing any sort of alternative type of therapy.
Wishing you and your family all the best!
in reply to: GD with TED #1184522mojon wrote:Any info on GD people/groups in Missouri?Hello – The GDATF is *very* small, so we only have a handful of in-person support groups, and we unfortunately don’t have coverage in Missouri. This forum is a great resource, and we are also active on Facebook (if you do a search on Facebook for GDATF, that will pull up our page).
in reply to: GD with TED #1184519Hello and welcome!
Rituximab is considered an experimental therapy for TED. One study overseas showed great results, but another study in the U.S. did not show improvement. Researchers are still trying to figure out the reason for the differing results, although the U.S. group was in general older, had higher antibody levels, and did not get diagnosed as quickly.
There are cases where patients with Hashimoto’s thyroiditis (which causes hypothyroidism) end up getting diagnosed with Graves’ disease years later. In other cases, patients with Graves’ disease can end up flipping hypo.
In terms of deciding whether the disease is stable, some doctors rely on antibody tests (like TSI), but in most cases, doctors will rely on whether your double vision is improving, worsening, or stable. Doctors like to see a few months of stability before doing surgery, as they don’t want to put you through a second surgery if the eyes change again.
TSH is a substance produced by the pituitary gland that either directs the thyroid gland to produce more hormone or to put the brakes on thyroid hormone production. The amount of TSH produced generally depends on a “feedback loop” according to where our thyroid hormone levels (T3 and T4) are. When T3/T4 are too high (hypER) the pituitary shuts down production of TSH to try and tell the thyroid to stop producing extra hormone. When T3/T4 are too low (hypO) the pituitary cranks out TSH to get the thyroid to produce MORE thyroid hormone. (With Graves’, the feedback loop can be interrupted, with TSH staying suppressed, even though T3/T4 are in the “normal” range.) Although thyroid eye disease can occur at any time – even with no thyroid dysfunction or years after treatment – being hyper or hypo does increase the risk of eye issues. So this is why your doctor is running blood tests – and hopefully he/she is working with you on getting your levels balanced.
You might be interested in checking out the GDATF’s videos on YouTube, as there is a lot of great information on thyroid eye disease presented by experts in the field:
(Note on links: if you click directly on the following link, you will need to use your browser’s “back” button to return to the boards after viewing, or you will have to log back in to the forum. As an alternative, you can right-click the link and open it in a new tab or new window).https://www.youtube.com/user/GravesAndThyroid/videos
You might also check out the “Men With Graves’ and TED” thread towards the top of the forum.
Take care!
in reply to: Is it normal to alternate dosage like this? #1184511Block & Replace is definitely not the standard of care in the U.S., although it *is* sometimes used for cases where patients (particularly children) are having difficulty getting stabilized on anti-thyroid meds.
There was a study out of Asia many years ago that indicated higher remission rates with B&R, but it was never replicated in other parts of the world – and there is concern about the potential risk of side effects that comes with using a larger dose of anti-thyroid meds.
Alternating doses is very common. I think the trick is to find a routine that will work for you to remember the days with different doses, so that might be why your doc recommended the weekend days.
Towards the end of my time on methimazole, I was taking a small dose on Mondays and Fridays only.
in reply to: Functioning with Graves- the new normal… #1184500Great info – thanks for sharing your story!
One note about diet is that there is a LOT of conflicting information out there. We’ve heard from patients who have done paleo, vegan, anti-inflammatory, low iodine, and eliminating food sensitivities based on testing. At this point, there isn’t any good research to show that one of these is more effective for Graves’ than the others. Of course, focusing on nutrient-dense whole foods and cutting down on processed foods with unpronounceable ingredients is always a good thing!
in reply to: On Week 12 and very discouraged #1184486Hello – I know from personal experience that the weight issues are VERY frustrating. However, your #1 priority right now is to get your thyroid levels back in balance. If it’s been a few weeks since you’ve had labs, it would be worth having this done just to see if the dose needs to be tweaked again. However, I would not recommend arbitrarily lowering the dose because of weight gain.
Weight issues are very individual – many patients struggle with excess weight gain, some struggle with having too much weight loss, and others have no issues at all. Also, keep in mind that if you lost an unhealthy amount of weight before diagnosis, the weight gain is actually a sign that you are getting back on the path to good health.
-
AuthorPosts
